Does the crisis constitute a threat to democracy?

The president of the European Parliament criticizes the democratic deficit in Brussels and Europe's failure in the crisis. In the run-up to the "2013 Debates on Europe ("Reden über Europa 2013") in Cologne, Martin Schulz warns of an erosion of democracy and Europe losing its significance as a global competitive force. Only if Europe represents its values credibly can it regain the trust of the population and remain competitive at a global level.


"The European Union as a whole is currently under threat. In Germany the approval ratings are at an all-time low and in parts of southern Europe the EU is perceived as an anonymous occupying power. We must therefore restore the trust of Europe's citizens.  To this end the European Union must become more democratic. Because Europe is deprived of the principle of the separation of powers which invigorates democracy at the national and regional level!" notes the president of the European Parliament, Martin Schulz, in Cologne's historical town hall on Sunday.  The Allianz Cultural Foundation (Allianz Kulturstiftung) had invited Schulz as keynote speaker at this year's Debates on Europe, which the company has been organizing throughout Europe since 2006. The topic had an alarming note to it in the cathedral city and filled the piazetta of Cologne's town hall to the last seat: "Democracy in danger – How the crisis is shaking the foundations of Europe".

 

In his passionate plea for more democracy in Europe, Schulz did not hold back on criticizing the decision-making practice in Brussels: during the crisis the heads of state and government in the European Council have consistently empowered themselves to make decisions bypassing their parliaments.  This "permanent state of emergency" would result in a gradual downgrading of the role of parliaments in Europe, to a disempowerment of both national representative bodies and the European Parliament. Thus, for example, Schulz thinks it is a disgrace that the European Parliament, with its democratically elected representatives from all EU member states, does not have its own right of initiative to propose new draft legislation - as the Bundestag and Bundesrat, as well as the government, are allowed to do in Germany. 

 

Martin Schulz severely criticizes the European Council for behaving like Europe's government. Ultimately, however, each of the 27 heads of state represented in this Council primarily pursues their own national interests. Since the Council is only permitted to make its decisions based on the principle of unanimity, the present-day EU is like a "giant with leaden feet" who is unable to respond to the changes in the world as efficiently and quickly as required. Comparing Europe to a giant with leaden feet also happens to be the title of his new book which appeared in the book shops a few hours beforehand ("Der gefesselte Riese  - Europas letzte Chance , Rowohlt Verlag - literally translated as "the tied-up giant - Europe's last chance").

 

According to Parliament President Schulz, the important decisions should be made on the basis of the principle of subsidiarity at the locations where people are directly affected by them. "The more local, the better". Above all Brussels lacks a "decision-making hierarchy": "what can be done at the national level should be of no concern". However, where the "strength of the community" is needed, the EU is called for. Therefore Schulz calls for further developing the democractic system in Europe, along with its rights and responsibilities, its values and liberties which are unique in the world. Only a democratic, transparent and value-based Europe which actively involves its citizens in shaping the future can be saved from fading into global insignificance.

Does the crisis constitute a threat to democracy?
The attention and the subsequent applause of the audience showed that Europe - at least in the metropolis on the Rhine - does not appear to be as unpopular as many had feared.

The attention and the subsequent applause of the audience showed that Europe - at least in the metropolis on the Rhine - does not appear to be as unpopular as many had feared.

Following his political keynote address on European politics, Martin Schulz entered a debate with the German Constitutional Court judge Susanne Baer and the author Navid Kermani. The discussion was moderated by Joachim Frank, chief reporter of the daily Kölner Stadtanzeiger newspaper, who together with the broadcaster Westdeutscher Rundfunk are media partners of the Allianz Cultural Foundation. The political and legal scientist Baer pointed out the increasing "social distortions" which prevent many young people form taking part in society. "Precarity these days does not only mean being unemployed, but also having no hope of ever getting a job". This hopelessness results in more and more people having doubts about the European project. The Hannah-Arendt laureate Kermani pointed out that the current crisis is not only a financial, economic or sovereign debt crisis, but one that reflects a profound political crisis of the EU which dates back quite a number of years. For many years, he argues, European politicians have been treating the European Community badly and downright contemptuously, so that he is not surprised that public opinion turned increasingly negative. Short-term national interest, usually dictated by upcoming elections, were put above long-term European concerns. Martin Schulz could only confirm this view and spoke of a "blame game" which broke out after every summit meeting of the EU heads of state and government: every single member then gives a press conference in which he illustrates how he asserted the interests of his electorate against those of other Europeans. 

According to Schulz "Europe can only function in a complementary manner when it comes to issues that are unable to be suitably dealt with by sovereign states." The Parliament President, who is said to have ambitions to have himself elected as Commission President at the next European elections in 2014, is hoping for the emergence of a new community spirit which not only Europe, but also the rest of the world, urgently needs to solve the major problems of our time: whether it be the tackling of climate change and associated hunger catastrophes, demographic developments and global migratory flows, the containment of speculative financial dealings or the economic crisis. To this extent Europe must and can act as a model for other regions of the world by "communitizing" important areas and speaking with one voice.

The attention and the subsequent applause of the audience showed that Europe - at least in the metropolis on the Rhine - does not appear to be as unpopular as many had feared. The sentiment in London and Bucharest, where the series of debates of the Allianz Cultural Foundation will be hosted next, will no doubt be more of a mixed bag.

As with all content published on this site, these statements are subject to our Forward Looking Statement disclaimer:

Michael M. Thoss
Allianz Kulturstiftung
Phone +49.30.209.157.31-30
Send e-mail