Superstorm Haiyan: Is climate change to blame?

Typhoon Haiyan is one of the most violent storms to ever have raged in Southeast Asia. Millions of people have been affected. Now the media is asking whether global warming is to blame for the natural catastrophe. Dr. Markus Stowasser, a meteorologist at Allianz explains, how such a superstorm can occur, to what extent global warming is at fault and how it is affecting one of the poorest and worst insured regions in the world – the Philippines.  

 

Haiyan shows how devastating typhoons can be. Are these superstorms man made? Is climate change responsible for catastrophes like this?
 

Man-made greenhouse gas emissions caused a clear upward trend in sea surface temperatures which are the heat engine for tropical storms. However, globally, the changes in tropical cyclone activity cannot be attributed only to human influence due to the large natural variability of the climate system and changes in observation techniques. Beside temperature, there are other factors which influence tropical cyclone activity such as wind shear, steering currents and aerosol loading of the atmosphere. For example in the North Atlantic region studies suggest that a reduction of the amount of aerosol has contributed at least in part to the observed increase in tropical cyclone activity since the 1970s. According to the newest IPCC report, projections for the 21st century using climate models indicate that it is likely that the global frequency of tropical cyclones will either decrease or remain essentially unchanged, concurrent with a likely increase in both global mean tropical cyclone maximum wind speed and rain rates.
 

Some of the media see this typhoon as a message to the Climate Change Conference taking place in Warsaw at the moment. Do you agree?
 

Most studies suggest that climate change will cause more frequent and severe extreme events especially when it comes to heat waves, droughts and heavy precipitation in the future. For example a study by the German Insurance Association shows a potential doubling of losses due to river flooding before the end of the century. Although a single event like super-typhoon Haiyan cannot prove climate change, it does remind us of our responsibility for future generations.

Markus Stowasser: "Haiyan was definitely one of the strongest and most powerful storms on record, however whether it was the strongest ever remains to be determined."
Markus Stowasser: "Haiyan was definitely one of the strongest and most powerful storms on record, however whether it was the strongest ever remains to be determined." 
The degree of destruction on the Philippines is yet to be determined.

The degree of destruction on the Philippines is yet to be determined.

We’re hearing that 2,500 people have died because of Typhoon Haiyan and that it was the strongest storm ever recorded. What factors and peculiarities made it so strong and devastating?
 

It was a combination of warm sea surface temperatures and low wind shear, which are the ingredients needed to make a storm very powerful. There was also a strong storm surge component, with around 15 feet surge right at the coastline. That has a high impact in terms of damage for Asia. Additionally, most of the wooden houses were not able to withstand the wind speeds caused by Haiyan. It can be assumed that damage to these types of dwellings will be total. Haiyan was definitely one of the strongest and most powerful storms on record, however whether it was the strongest ever remains to be determined.
 

As storms interact with the topography after making landfall, they can either die out or be prolonged. How did Typhoon Haiyan interact with the landscape in the Philippines? We’ve heard it passed over and kept going? Why?
 

This was another striking thing about this storm. The Philippines are fairly mountainous but not a continuous uninterrupted landmass - there is water between islands. But nevertheless, the impact caused by interaction with the topography there was minimal and Haiyan left the islands, still a Category 4 storm – still a very powerful typhoon. It was only slightly weakened by its interaction with the topography of the Philippines.
 

The most active area for storms is the Northwest Pacific, is the Philippines coastline affected by this? How much of a threat is this active basin to the coastlines around it?
 

The Philippine islands are sitting right in middle of the main activity region of the Northwestern Pacific which is the most active region for typhoons, so it is definitely not unusual for a typhoon, or a super typhoon to hit them. There have certainly been lots of them in the recent past. On average, there are 4.3 typhoons making landfall per year. So people are used to such phenomena. But with Haiyan, a Category 5, the impact is very severe.
 

How well is this region of the Philippines insured?
 

The estimates state around ten to 20 per cent insurance penetration rate in this area, which is quite low. One aspect of such catastrophes as this typhoon, is that they may bring decision makers to take the risks more seriously and start thinking about prevention and building regulation measures, which are all necessary prerequisites for insurability. 

What we call a hurricane in the Atlantic, is named a typhoon in the South Pacific or Indian Ocean. Because water in the Pacific warms up significantly more in the summer months than the water in the Atlantic, the number of typhoons is significantly higher than the number of hurricanes. On average, a water temperature of 26.5 degrees is necessary. Then the spiral of destruction begins. Water evaporates in large quantities and flows upwards. In the cold air areas, further up, the water cools down, condenses and collects, creating large cloud formations. Beneath these clouds an area of low pressure is created, air flows around this and rises to the top. Because of the earth's rotation air does not flow evenly, it swirls upwards, and a typical typhoon or hurricane movement arises.

As with all content published on this site, these statements are subject to our Forward Looking Statement disclaimer:

 

Christiane Merkel
Allianz SE
Phone +49.89.3800-18195
Send e-mail

Katerina Piro
Allianz SE
Phone +49.89.3800-16048
Send e-mail