Are pandemics insurable?

As a result, insurers have come under fire. They argue that pandemics are not insurable and insurance cover cannot be provided. Allianz, however, is working on solutions for the future. 

Insurers cover risks for a premium – that is a fundamental aspect of the insurance industry, and one that is the backbone of coverage for a wide range of risks, across the world. However, why is it that a pandemic is deemed to be a step out of reach and uninsurable? "As an insurer, we can only offer insurance cover for risks that can be insured according to the principles of actuarial mathematics. A pandemic is not one of them," explains Klaus-Peter Röhler, CEO of Allianz Germany and member of the Board of Management of Allianz SE. 

An insurance coverage functions according to the "principle of large numbers": many people pay a comparatively low premium so that those who incur damages will receive a larger sum of money. In order for this approach to be actuarially representable, the risks must be statistically assessable and sufficiently independent from each other. Only in this way can risks be spread according to parameters such as time axis, geography or type of damage, which then results in comparatively low premiums. This is precisely where it would be problematic in the insurance of pandemics: "The criterion of independent risks is not met in the case of a pandemic, since business interruptions occur almost simultaneously anywhere in the world and can be traced back to a single cause – the COVID-19 virus," explains Röhler.

As a result, a huge protection gap is created which must be closed. The Geneva Association, the leading international insurer think tank of which Allianz is a member, has just published a study sponsored by Allianz and AIG. "According to this study, less than one percent of the estimated global GDP damage caused by the pandemic, amounting to 4.5 trillion U.S. dollars (source: World Bank) for 2020, will be covered by business interruption insurance," says Röhler. 

The disparity between the economic losses and the capacity of business interruption insurers to assume risks is shocking, he says. "According to the study, with annual business interruption insurance premiums of around 30 billion U.S. dollars, insurance customers will have to pay premiums for 150 years to offset the estimated global production loss of 4.5 trillion U.S. dollars for 2020," says Röhler.

Klaus-Peter Roehler
Klaus-Peter Röhler, CEO of Allianz Germany and member of the Board of Management of Allianz SE

Röhler sees a solution for the next pandemic in cooperation between the insurance industry and the state. "We want to play an active and anticipatory role in providing coverage for any possible future pandemics, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), in a more predictable and faster manner right from the start," says Röhler. In order to achieve this goal in the most effective way, Allianz experts recommend developing special pandemic coverage for the European markets in cooperation with the local insurance industry and government. "That would make comprehensive coverage for companies broadly available," says Röhler. Insurers would take on the coverage up to a contractually-agreed level. If that level were exceeded, the rest would be covered by the state.

The solution should be mandatory. "With a voluntary solution, there would be no blanket coverage," says Röhler. It would be a patchwork. On top of that, a voluntary solution would make it even more difficult to keep premiums affordable if prices are calculated correctly. "We absolutely want to avoid that.” 

Initially, the target of such protection should only be pandemics. "In our opinion, there is a lot to be said for not including other systemic risks such as terrorism or cyberattacks in this solution, as otherwise the pricing would be extremely complex, due to the interplay of several risks.“ 

In addition, the solution should initially be developed for SMEs and the self-employed, in order to protect those that are most affected by pandemic-related business closures and to ensure that certain fixed costs are covered for a given period of time. For large enterprises, more tailored insurance solutions would make sense. 

"It’s important to us that a clear, easy-to-understand trigger is defined, upon which the pandemic solution would take effect and enable rapid and standardized claims payments," says Röhler. How to deal with not only the direct but also the indirect effects like, for example, the impact on travel agencies due to travel restrictions must also be considered carefully.

In view of the interdependence of the European economies, Allianz considers it sensible to embed this concept in an overarching EU framework with minimum requirements. "However, implementation should take place at national level and be adapted to the individual countries," explains Röhler, "because the laws for cushioning the effects of a pandemic, such as the short-time work law in Germany for example, differ from country to country. “ 

Regardless of which path is ultimately taken in the individual countries, "from Allianz-perspective, it’s important the solution guarantees a simple, efficient, and reliable claims handling and payment process, in order to provide customers with fast and meaningful support in the event of the next pandemic," says Röhler.

But that is not the only lesson Röhler draws from this crisis: "The corona pandemic has accelerated the trend towards greater sustainability. This is a unique opportunity that we must seize." Röhler interprets the term broadly: "For me, acting sustainably means actively contributing to mastering the central ecological, economic and social challenges. That is part of our DNA as insurers. This is why we integrate climate protection into the core business of our divisions, the investment and insurance business. For example, we are working hard to ensure that all policyholder funds are invested in a climate-neutral manner by 2050. Money that Allianz customers receive from their insurance and investment products will therefore be generated increasingly in a CO2-neutral way.” 

In the current situation, Röhler sees it not only as a core task to be prepared for the next pandemic, but also to take a more active role in global risks. "In order to live up to our ambition of being more sustainable, we must anticipate rather than just react." The next global crisis is already waiting – a global cyberattack is a very realistic scenario, just like climate change. "Both risks are systemic and therefore cannot be managed by insurers alone," says Röhler. "What we need is an overarching partnership approach by the insurance industry, businesses and governments to develop solutions together. We are working on this with high priority.“

The Allianz Group is one of the world's leading insurers and asset managers with more than 100 million retail and corporate customers in more than 70 countries. Allianz customers benefit from a broad range of personal and corporate insurance services, ranging from property, life and health insurance to assistance services to credit insurance and global business insurance. Allianz is one of the world’s largest investors, managing around 774 billion euros on behalf of its insurance customers. Furthermore, our asset managers PIMCO and Allianz Global Investors manage 1.7 trillion euros of third-party assets. Thanks to our systematic integration of ecological and social criteria in our business processes and investment decisions, we hold the leading position for insurers in the Dow Jones Sustainability Index. In 2019, over 147,000 employees achieved total revenues of 142 billion euros and an operating profit of 11.9 billion euros for the group.

These assessments are, as always, subject to the disclaimer provided below.

Press contacts

Susanne Seemann
Allianz SE
As with all content published on this site, these statements are subject to our cautionary note regarding forward-looking statements:
Disclaimer

Further information

Earthquake and Fire Research Center in Turkey expands family of Allianz research centers

The family of Allianz Centers for Technology is growing. With the Allianz Teknik Earthquake and Fire Testing and Training Center in Turkey, three Allianz Group research centers are now available to support customers and society in loss prevention, improve products and processes, and increase the operational safety of systems and consumer goods.

Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE embarks on global transformation program

Under its new leadership, Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty (AGCS), the industrial insurer of Allianz Group, announces a comprehensive transformation program, “New AGCS”, to regain profitability and market leadership in the corporate and specialty insurance segment.

Insurance Outlook 2020: A Lost Year

Coronavirus will keep the insurance industry in weak health this year. But the pandemic could accelerate emerging trends in the industry. Digitalization, ESG and Asia are some keywords to watch, says the latest Allianz Global Insurance Report...